Carrier vetting checklist for freight brokers
Before you tender a load, run sixteen checks: identity, authority, insurance, safety record and fraud signals, including out-of-service rates, inspection history, MCS-150 recency and double-brokering red flags. Pass or stop on each, and keep a dated record.
The 16 checks
| # | Check | Pass | Stop or escalate | Free lookup | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Identity matches the paperwork | Legal name, DBA and city on the rate confirmation match the FMCSA record for the USDOT or MC number given. | Name, city or number does not match what the dispatcher told you. | Carrier Lookup by USDOT or MC number | FMCSA company census (data.transportation.gov) |
| 2 | USDOT status is active | USDOT status shows active. | Inactive USDOT number: FMCSA treats the company as out of operation. | Carrier Lookup, SAFER | FMCSA SAFER company snapshot |
| 3 | MC number belongs to the same USDOT number | The MC number on the carrier packet resolves to the same USDOT number and company. | MC and USDOT point to different companies, or the MC number does not exist. | Carrier Lookup by MC number | FMCSA licensing and insurance data (Motus) |
| 4 | Carrier authority is active | Active carrier authority (MC or MX) for interstate for-hire freight. | Broker-only or freight-forwarder-only authority, or no active authority. | Carrier Lookup authority section | FMCSA licensing and insurance data (Motus) |
| 5 | Authority age | Active longer than your own minimum (brokers commonly set 30, 90 or 180 days). | Under your minimum, or recently reinstated: add the extra checks below or decline. | New authority guide, Carrier Lookup authority dates | FMCSA authority grant dates (Motus) |
| 6 | No suspension or revocation notice | No involuntary suspension or revocation notice on file. | A served notice: the authority stops on its effective date unless the carrier fixes the problem. | FMCSA revocations list | FMCSA authority revocation and suspension notices |
| 7 | BOC-3 process agent on file | A BOC-3 filing is on record for the authority. | No BOC-3: the authority is not in force without a process agent. | BOC-3 lookup | 49 CFR Part 366 (designation of process agents) |
| 8 | MCS-150 updated within the last 24 months | The last MCS-150 update on FMCSA’s record is under two years old. | Older than 24 months, or the date is blank: the carrier’s own profile may be stale or abandoned. | MCS-150 due date checker | 49 CFR 390.201 (biennial MCS-150 update) |
| 9 | Insurance on file meets the minimum | BIPD on file at or above the required minimum (usually $750,000 for general freight) with no pending cancellation. | BIPD below the minimum, no filing, or a cancellation date approaching. | FMCSA insurance lookup | 49 CFR 387.9 (financial responsibility minimums) |
| 10 | Certificate confirmed with the insurer | You called the insurer or agent on a number you found yourself and cargo limits and exclusions fit the load. | Certificate came only from the carrier by email, or the insurer cannot confirm it. | Insurer or agent, by phone | Your own call; FMCSA insurance filings show the insurer name |
| 11 | Safety rating and its date | Satisfactory, or unrated (most carriers are unrated, which is normal). | Unsatisfactory: do not use. Conditional: ask what was corrected. | Carrier Lookup, SAFER | FMCSA SAFER company snapshot |
| 12 | Out-of-service rates against the national average | Vehicle and driver out-of-service rates at or below the national averages printed next to them on SAFER. | Either rate clearly above the national average, or a recent out-of-service order. | SAFER inspection summary, SMS | FMCSA SAFER inspection summary, 24 months |
| 13 | Inspection history exists and is recent | Inspections in the last 24 months, enough to read a rate from; crashes in line with the fleet size. | A fleet that runs but shows no inspections, or a crash count out of proportion to its power units. | SAFER, FMCSA SMS | FMCSA Safety Measurement System |
| 14 | Contact details verified independently | You reached the company on a phone number you found yourself, and the email domain matches its website. | Free-mail address, new email domain, recently changed phone number or a rush to book. | Your own phone call | Your own call; compare with the FMCSA census phone and address |
| 15 | Double-brokering red flags | The carrier on the bill of lading, the truck and driver at pickup, and the carrier you vetted are the same company. | Different MC number on the paperwork, a rate far below the market, a driver who cannot name the dispatcher or a rush to change the pickup details. | How to vet a carrier, your pickup check | FMCSA carrier identity and registration records |
| 16 | Confirm on SAFER and keep a record | You checked FMCSA SAFER on the day you tender and saved what you saw with the date. | The record on tender day differs from what you vetted earlier. | safer.fmcsa.dot.gov, your file | FMCSA SAFER company snapshot |
Last reviewed 2026-11-18. Public FMCSA data cannot prove a carrier is safe, only what it filed and what FMCSA recorded. Sources: FMCSA open data on data.transportation.gov (company census, Motus authority and insurance files) and FMCSA SAFER. The $750,000 figure is the federal minimum for general freight (49 CFR 387.9); household goods and hazmat carriers need more.
How to use it
- Run the carrier through the DOT number lookup; the identity, authority, insurance and revocation checks are on the result page.
- Do the insurer call, the contact check, the pickup check and SAFER by phone and on the FMCSA site.
- Print the PDF, tick each line, and file it with the rate confirmation.
Reuse it: the checklist is free to copy with credit (CC BY 4.0). Cite as:
Carrier Lookup. Carrier vetting checklist for freight brokers: 16 checks with FMCSA sources. Reviewed 2026-11-18. https://dotcarriercheck.com/carrier-vetting-checklist
Why each check matters, and how our verdict reads the data, is in how to vet a carrier. New authorities need extra care: see the new authority guide. Quoting an LTL load? The freight class calculator turns pallet size and weight into a density class.
Frequently asked questions
›What should a broker check before tendering a load?
Match the carrier’s identity, confirm active USDOT status and active carrier authority, check authority age, BOC-3 and MCS-150 recency, check insurance on file and confirm it with the insurer, read the safety rating, out-of-service rates and inspection history, look for suspension notices and double-brokering red flags, and check SAFER on tender day.
›Is the PDF free?
Yes. The PDF has a tick box per check and a line for the carrier name, USDOT number and date; the CSV has the same rows plus Done, Result and Notes columns for your own file. No signup.
›Can public FMCSA data prove a carrier is safe?
No. It shows what the carrier filed and what FMCSA recorded. It cannot show that the person on the phone works for the carrier or that the truck at the dock belongs to it.