Skip to main content

How to vet a carrier before you tender a load

Ten checks, about ten minutes. The first eight use FMCSA’s public data, which our DOT number lookup puts on one page; the last two you do by phone and on SAFER.

  1. Match the identity. Look the carrier up by the USDOT or MC number on its paperwork and check the legal name, DBA and city match what the dispatcher told you.
  2. USDOT status is active. An inactive USDOT number means FMCSA considers the company out of operation. Stop there.
  3. Carrier authority is active, not only broker authority. A company with broker authority only cannot haul your load itself. Interstate for-hire freight needs active carrier authority (MC or MX).
  4. Check how old the authority is. Authority active under 90 days is new; many brokers require 30 to 180 days, or extra checks before then. Reinstated authority counts as new too.
  5. Insurance on file meets the requirement. BIPD on file must be at least the required minimum (usually $750,000 for general freight). Look for pending cancellations.
  6. Get the certificate from the insurer. Ask for a certificate of insurance and confirm it with the insurer or agent on a number you found yourself, including cargo limits and exclusions.
  7. Read the safety rating and its date. Unsatisfactory: do not use. Conditional: ask what was corrected. Most carriers are unrated, which is normal.
  8. Look for suspension or revocation notices. A served involuntary suspension notice means the authority stops on its effective date unless the carrier fixes the problem.
  9. Verify contact details independently. Call the number you found for the company, not the one in the email. Mismatched email domains and recently changed phone numbers are classic identity-theft signs.
  10. Confirm on SAFER and keep a record. Check FMCSA’s SAFER snapshot on the day you tender, and save what you checked with the date.

Want it on paper? Use the carrier vetting checklist or download the PDF.

How our verdict reads the data

  • Stop: inactive USDOT number, no active carrier authority, unsatisfactory rating, BIPD below the minimum, or a suspension notice with a future effective date.
  • Caution: authority active under 90 days (new authority), under a year (young), conditional rating, a pending insurance cancellation, or cargo cover required but missing.
  • Note: broker-only companies, intrastate carriers and private carriers, which aren’t bad but can’t haul interstate freight for hire.
  • No red flags: none of the above. It is still a reading of public data, not a guarantee.

What public data can’t tell you

FMCSA data can’t prove that the person on the phone works for the carrier, that the truck at the dock belongs to it, or that the insurance certificate in your inbox is real. Those checks are yours: independent phone verification, the insurer’s confirmation, and matching the driver and equipment at pickup. We deliberately don’t show phone numbers or emails from FMCSA data, because fraudsters copy them.

Chameleon carriers

A chameleon, or reincarnated, carrier is the same business operating under a new name and authority to leave behind a poor safety record, unpaid claims or an enforcement action. FMCSA’s rule on reincarnated carriers, 49 CFR 386.73, looks for “substantial continuity between the entities” and common ownership or control, weighing shared management, equipment, insurance and addresses. You can see the same signs from the outside: compare the new carrier’s contact name, phone number, email domain and address with carriers you have used or stopped using. A new authority whose details match a former carrier is a reason to stop and ask questions. Read the rule on eCFR.

Confirm identity with the driver and the truck

At pickup, match the driver and the equipment to the carrier you vetted. Check that the company name and USDOT number on the truck door match the carrier on your rate confirmation and in FMCSA’s record. If the name or number differs, or the driver names a different company, do not load until you have called the carrier on a number you looked up yourself.

Confirm insurance with the insurer

FMCSA’s record shows the insurance filed, not that a certificate sent to you is genuine. Find the insurer or agent on the FMCSA licensing and insurance site, get their phone number from the insurer’s own website, not from the certificate or the carrier’s email, and ask them to confirm the policy, limits and effective dates.

Authority under about six months

There is no legal minimum age for authority, but brokers commonly wait 30 to 180 days or add checks. For authority under about six months, add checks you would skip for an established carrier: trade references you call yourself, insurance confirmed with the insurer, a lower-value first load, and a comparison of its contact details with former carriers. Our new MC list shows when authorities were granted.

Fraud can be reported: FMCSA has a page on broker and carrier fraud and identity theft. If you book the same carriers repeatedly, see free vs paid carrier monitoring tools.

New to MC and DOT numbers? Read MC number vs DOT number.

Frequently asked questions

›How long should a carrier’s authority be active before I use it?

There is no legal minimum. Brokers commonly set 30, 90 or 180 days. If you load newer authorities, add identity and insurance checks and watch for double brokering.

›What insurance should a carrier have on file?

For general freight, at least $750,000 of BIPD liability filed with FMCSA. Household goods and hazmat carriers need more, and FMCSA requires cargo insurance only for household goods. Your shipper contract may require cargo cover regardless.

›Does an unrated carrier mean it is unsafe?

No. Most carriers have never had a compliance review, so they are unrated. Only Conditional and Unsatisfactory ratings are negative findings.

›What is double brokering?

A company accepts your load as a carrier, then re-brokers it to another carrier without your consent, often under a stolen or new authority. Payment disputes and cargo theft follow. Identity checks and authority age catch most of it.